Tuesday 19 February 2013

REVIEW - NO


A spirited account of Chile's escape from the clutches of dictatorship in 1988, Pablo Larrain's No makes up for its lack of innovation with its brio and sense of humour, partially at least. It almost approaches docudrama territory with the frequent footage of the ad campaigns run by opposing sides in the plebiscite, and this footage is the most revealing and entertaining aspect of No. Production details are excellent in their evocation of the era, and the faux-authentic filming style is only occasionally tacky, and mostly successful. Larrain achieves a feeling of immediacy throughout, keeping the flow of scenes brisk, the camera close and intimate, the performances bright and natural. It's somewhat sloppy, though, and both verbose enough that you'll need to pay constant attention, yet often lacking in clarity, or even pertinence - many characters barely register, and their petty squabbles add neither humour nor dramatic depth. Larrain adds a jolt of tension every now and then, but to little avail; it's always short-lived, and ultimately only clutters the tone of the film. All of this is why the contemporary ad footage is so much more interesting - it has been created with purpose, a greater purpose than No can aspire to today, and one which it has its sights firmly set on. Larrain is generous with his use of it, though, which is welcome, and also necessary, considering its centrality to the story. No is, then, an appealing but slightly frustrating and unsatisfying film, generally well-executed but a tad unmemorable.

15 comments:

  1. Nice work here Paddy! There is a sense of urgency for sure and a humorous undertow to an ugly political climate. I thought Bernal was exceptional and the film contained a number of arresting moments. Still, I'd agree the film (which I just saw on Saturday night) could have been greater despite the director's tension infused work. I would say that at least in a partial sense the sloppy camera work does add to the cinema verite look of the film.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did quite like the camera work. It was the overall direction that I found a little sloppy.

      Gael Garcia Bernal was very good, you're right.

      Delete
  2. 2013 Costume Designers Guild Awards.

    >> = victory.

    EXCELLENCE IN PERIOD FILM
    >>Anna Karenina - Jacqueline Durran
    Argo - Jacqueline West
    Les Misérables - Paco Delgado
    Lincoln - Joanna Johnston
    Moonrise Kingdom - Kasia Walicka-Maimone

    EXCELLENCE IN CONTEMPORARY FILM
    Beasts of the Southern Wild - Stephani Lewis
    The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel - Louise Stjernsward
    Silver Linings Playbook - Mark Bridges
    >>Skyfall - Jany Temime
    Zero Dark Thirty - George L. Little

    EXCELLENCE IN FANTASY FILM
    Cloud Atlas - Kym Barrett, Pierre-Yves Gayraud
    The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey - Ann Maskrey, Richard Taylor, Bob Buck
    The Hunger Games - Judianna Makovsky
    >>Mirror Mirror - Eiko Ishioka
    Snow White and the Huntsman - Colleen Atwood

    ReplyDelete
  3. SATURN AWARDS NOMINATIONS -
    http://www.saturnawards.org/nominations.html

    ReplyDelete
  4. Brother, top ten list?
    Gonna be on Razzies day or Oscar Day?
    Sorry for being such a persistent weed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Weed?!? Lol you're no weed! There are two people who kindly comment on my shitty blog - you and Sam! You guys are what keep me going!

      Top ten list on Sunday!

      Delete
  5. That's way too humble.
    But your site is not shitty, nowhere remotely close.
    Believe me, brother.
    It's non-flashier aesthetics is what has grown on me.
    Honestly, you've better knowledge and worthier thoughts than half of the critics and award followers out on internet.
    You ought to give yourself credit for being the one of the most ardent, devoted and dedicated cinephile who is willing to listen to anybody listening to you . Where do you find such people without being overly hypocritical and hyperbolic?
    And your reviews are always short, sweet, considerably critical and pleasure to read.
    It is not shitty by any stretch of imagination.
    More like a central library run by sovereign government who knows what its doing.
    Its not flattering, but the truth itself.
    Have deep respect of you and your site.
    Thank you for the opportunity.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're way too nice. Are you a manifestation of some part of my subconscious of which I have been unaware until now? I think you might be my self-confidence. I was wondering where that had gotten to...

      Delete
  6. Narp. No way. No matter how you twist and turn, its in your mind safe and sound.
    The manifestation of subconscious is in your writings, reviews and focus. Read 'em again, please.
    It's an outlandish mistake in extrapolating your intellectual with my words. Totally unbecoming. Haven't written a single sound article/essay in my whole English exams and its done.
    Am just a lost Freddie Quell in life trying to understand films juggling the inevitable academics with very little success.
    My taste in movies is not all that good..
    Your views and vision is what inspires me even though there are some disagreements.
    Adore you work than most, that's all.
    You shall not be very pleasant with my top ten. Mark my words, brother.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I want to know your top ten! When will you be revealing it? And I'll be pleasant! When am I ever not...? ;)

      One's taste in movies can be neither good nor bad. It's as good as it is to you.

      I'm gonna twist and turn and find any possible way of deflecting your praise lol! But you're ever so nice. I've yet to learn how to process compliments.

      Delete
  7. On the same day when you post your top ten, shall reply, if my hasn't PC screwed already.
    Just got to hold it together till Oscars at the least.

    My current Oscar predictions has Django Unchained and Argo going home empty handed.
    Django Unchained may go empty handed. Certainly a possibility.
    But betting against Argo is preposterous at the moment.
    Still, am going with my daft impossibilities, brother.
    Shall reply with my full predictions tomorrow.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kk. I look forward to your top ten. Mine's coming on Sunday, alongside a review of 2012 and my final Oscar predictions.

      This year is so unusual, Argo and Django could certainly both go home empty-handed. That'd be very interesting. Who knows what will happen. I hope that the results are as satisfying and surprising as the nominations were. I have a theory that years with surprising nominations have boring winners, and those with boring nominations have surprising winners. Recently, a lot of both has been boring, and disappointing to boot.

      Delete
    2. Totally agree with you.

      Delete
  8. My typing and english again, brother.
    Extremely sorry.
    First sentence.
    'my PC hasn't screwed already'.
    My bad.

    ReplyDelete